One Yves St Laurent dress, two women. Who looked better in this grey strapless dress? Rihanna with her bare legs, strappy heels, and eye-catching necklace? Or Gwyneth Paltrow with black jacket, black nylons, and booties?
I definitely think that while Gwyneth looks very pretty, Rihanna pulled it off best, she looks fantastic!

Both Eva Mendes and Jessica Alba wore the same Fendi dress at different events. Which one do you prefer?
Personally, I dislike the dress in general but I think it looked better on Eva with the bare legs than on Jessica with the dark tights.

I love when stars wear the same dress so you can see who wore it best. Carrie Underwood and Kim Kardashian wore the same glitzy gold Jovani dress at two different events (Carrie in December, Kim back in August). Who do you think looks better in it? I think that although Kim [...]

Christmas came early for Vanessa Hudgens and Rosario Dawson - this brightly colored number looks like Christmas wrap. Vanessa wore it to the US Hot Hollywood party and Rosario (who I love, by the way) showed up wearing the same dress the other day for Tao’s 2 year anniversary in Vegas.  
Props to Rosario for the purple shoes, though - at least they match [...]

Two beautiful women, two versions of the same gorgeous Dolce & Gabbana dress. Denise wore hers with straps, while Rose went strapless.

Seriously, can you decide who looks best? Because I can’t - I think they both look equally stunning.

I love when celebrities wear the same outfit. Both America Ferrera and Elisha Cuthbert wore a black and white Thakoon dress . Who wore it best?

I actually like it best on America just because she has curves which is always so nice to see.

At the Academy of Country Music Awards, everyone was abuzz that Shania Twain was wearing the same dress that Hayden Panettiere wore (except Shania used the straps and Hayden went strapless).
Both women looked gorgeous in the white and gold Monique Lhuillier gown. But who do you think looked best? I have to go [...]

Kelly Ripa wore this blue silk halter Graham & Spencer dress to The Late Show; Michelle Trachtenberg wore the same one to a fashion show in L.A.

Who pulls it off best?